My Photo
Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 02/2006

« In the case of land, the colonial administrators mostly got it right | Main | Playbook of a songwriter – serial monogamy in a what’s next game »

22 April 2019


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Philip Fitzpatrick

For anyone interested, this is what Wikipedia says about Lee Kwan Yew:

"Lee's rule was criticised for curtailing civil liberties (media control and limits on public protests) and bringing libel suits against political opponents.

He argued that such disciplinary measures were necessary for political stability which, together with rule of law, were essential for economic progress, famously saying:

'Anybody who decides to take me on needs to put on knuckle-dusters.

"If you think you can hurt me more than I can hurt you, try. There is no other way you can govern a Chinese society."

Is this the sort of leader PNG needs?

And Bainimarama is notorious for cracking down on media freedom. "It is not unusual for Fiji to intimidate and imprison journalists," an Australian professor of political science said recently - KJ

Philip Fitzpatrick

It's interesting that you mention Lee Kwan Yew of Singapore and Frank Bainimarima of Fiji Peter.

As I understand it Lee Kwan Yew was and Frank Bainimarima still is a so-called strongman who doesn't tolerate opposition kindly. I think Lee Kwan Yew was probably more strident in this case than Frank Bainimarima.

I'm not knocking them for that reason and agree that their achievements, especially Lee Kwan Yew's, are considerable.

Whether they represent benevolent dictatorship or autocratic democracy is an interesting question.

Either way, what they represent is probably what PNG needs right now.

Peter Sandery

Phil, you fail to mention either the late Lee Kwan Yew of Singapore or Frank Bainimarima of Fiji as role models for leadership, neither of whom have received their due from the media in Australia and New Zealand but both of whom, in my opinion, have done more to democratise their countries than most others.

It is unfortunate that the latest Singaporean generation appear, somewhat like Australians, to have had it too good for too long and the Lee hallmark appears to have lost some of its lustre.

As regards PNG, as I have said before, I think it like Islam, will get nowhere in the modern world until it has its own grass roots Reformation which must in both cases be self-generated but guided by non traditional methods.

Lindsay F Bond

Governor Gary Juffa expressed opinion (7/8/2018): “Going by the trend since 1975 16 September, the philosophy of 5 weeks dring bia na kaiak lamb flaps na 5 years kisim taim will most likely prevail. We shall choose followers, spineless cowards, crooks and not a few imbeciles.”

Taking a look at “followers”, it is hard not to notice a 2018 item by Michael Kabuni which includes:

“DSIP/PSIP funds

"Initially designed as electoral discretionary funds in 1984, these funds reached their height in 2013. K10 million was allocated per year for each of the MPs representing one of the 89 open electorates/districts through the DSIP; K5 million per electorate for each provincial MP (through the PSIP); and K500,000 for each local-level government.

"The relevant legislation and guidelines governing these funds do not state the specific dates and amounts to be given to the respective MPs.

"The government has been accused of exploiting this vacuum by deliberately withholding the DSIP and PSIP funds belonging to parliamentarians in the opposition, while releasing the funds to MPs who support the government.

"For instance in August 2016, the governor for Oro Province, Gary Juffa, who was critical of the government’s decisions, claimed that the national government only released K1 million for Oro Province instead of K10 million (i.e., K5 million each for the two open electorates in Oro). Sam Basil, the MP for Bulolo District, Belden Namah, the MP for Vanimo Green, and others made similar claims.

"A month after Peter O’Neil formed government in 2017, Sam Basil led 12 other MPs from Pangu Pati to cross over to the government side. As Pangu joined the government, Basil explained this decision as being driven by his MPs’ need to be able access DSIP funds, which he claimed may have been denied had they stayed in opposition.”


While it is the prerogative of PNG Parliament to pass into law methods to give effect to distribution of funds for national development and community welfare, there has arisen particular critical disquiet and even rebuke, at the operational outcomes of DSIP.

For instance, as early as 30/10/2014,Governor Gary Juffa put it that: “This has suddenly exposed the Two Open Members who have been using their Joint District Planning and Budget Prioritization Committees as procurement authorities…which is illegal…the laws do not allow that…the JDPBPC is merely a committee to prioritize the disbursement of DSIP funds.”

A question is, has this distribution methodology settled into electoral acceptability, or nonchalance?

A next question is, apart from an actual “need to be able access DSIP funds”, and a societal imperative to be visibly and effectively handling the produce of ‘platform’ (namely funding), can PNG democracy yet function sufficiently on trust of distributions through Departments of the Public Service?

Question too arises from the Juffa observation, that if societal preponderance gives rise to numerous self-interested elected representatives, is it any wonder that the queue is stood long at the trough?

Nomah Mambi

True indeed.

Philip Fitzpatrick

It's a truly dispiriting thing to list all the despots, maniacs and bloodthirsty leaders in the world because there are so many of them. I thought of mentioning Mugabe but hopefully he's now gone for good.

I was talking about Trump in the context of Morrison and May rather than in the context of all the bad and barbarous leaders of the world. What I dislike about Trump is his ego, his dishonesty, his lying and his manipulation of dumb white voters. But you could say that of Morrison too I guess.

What's also dispiriting about Morrison, May and Trump is considering the alternatives, Shorten, Corbyn and Biden. It's all so depressing.

It will be interesting to watch Adern. People have put her on a very high pedestal and it's a long way to the ground. I hope she can hold up over the coming years.

I also thought about mentioning both Mekere Morauta and Brian Kramer but decided they are nowhere near even a tenth of a Mandela. It would be nice to think I'm wrong about Kramer, he seems to have great courage but it might need more than that.

Robert Wilson

Hello Phil, great article which I mostly agree with. However, lucky for us, we are free to disagree with each other on these pages without being censored or feel like we are in a war zone because we dare to differ.

That's true freedom of speech, something which is sadly looking to diminish in our society.

You have shown your intense dislike of Trump through strong rhetoric yet nary a word about the mass murderers, genocidal maniacs and horrendously corrupt leaders that abound. Trump is none of these!

The French and Canadian leaders also deserve mention for their efforts in virtue signaling leadership. Look what has happened to those great countries and New Zealand's Adern is following along in their path so I would not be singing her praises just yet.

Anyway, we all despair of what PNG has become but one new young member, Brian Kramer from Madang is worthy of some respect. Whether, however, he can stand up to the constant pressure remains to be seen.

Raymond Sigimet

An ideal leader for PNG would have to be a "man of the people". Suitably an orator who can inspire attitude change and positive action in the people.

He or she should be passionated and visionary enough to envision a national development path that is for the people and have the " big" bigman in the Haus and "liklik" bigman in the public service walk with that vision.

Two important traits of modern leaders who have changed the cause of history or created change in their country was that they were great orators and the people listened to them; and they were firm in their resolve to create a great nation whatever the cost.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)