Those PNG colonial conflicts: a short examination of killing
Fear of change (& China) is driving Australia’s Pacific frenzy

Sorcery: Are education & demonstration parts of the answer?

Dr Betty Etami Koka
Dr Betty Etami Koka

ROSS WILKINSON

"Educating people and dispelling the myths around sorcery could prevent further sorcery accusations and result in fewer attacks… I suggested it would be good to do an open post mortem” - Dr Betty Koka, Head of Rural Health, Divine Word University

MELBOURNE - In 1978, when I was District Officer at Saidor in Madang Province, the brother of a prominent Saidor personality died at Madang Hospital.

Immediately the news was received at Saidor his family began agitating that he had been killed by sorcery, saying they intended to seek revenge from the group that allegedly had practised the sorcery.

The situation became problematic, so I sought advice from the provincial medical officer in Madang to bring the groups together to resolve the accusations and potential violence.

I was advised that the man had died of a brain aneurysm and was given a quick medical lecture on the condition.

My next step was to arrange for a meeting between the family and those they accused of sorcery against the deceased.

I arranged for several police to be within hailing distance but not present in the meeting room. Whilst those accused of sorcery admitted to a dispute with the dead man’s group, they claimed that it was not serious enough to have resulted in sorcery nor did they have any capacity to invoke it.

I then advised the groups that I had spoken to the medical authorities and proceeded to give them a medical lecture on the nature of brain aneurysms, their effect of how they could cause death, stressing this was not an unusual medical condition, many people in the world experienced it and it had nothing to do with sorcery. 

After a question and answer session, in which I emphasised that this was information from the doctor, the groups finally accepted this as a natural death and shook hands.

There were other instances in my time in Papua New Guinea where there were obvious conflicts between village people’s traditional magico-religious beliefs and their allegedly strong Christian beliefs. 

These generally took the form of carved totems of people, animals or other symbols placed strategically at the entrance to individual houses or the paths into the village.

The symbols were also positioned in village food gardens to ensure fertility for bountiful harvests.  Examples of these are in the Sepik men’s houses and there were some at Parliament House before their removal. 

When on patrol and approaching villages, I recall walking through garden areas with prominent carved phalluses as corner posts to the garden fences.

Having regard to the history of PNG and its people, whilst education is widespread and of a reasonable standard, this wasn’t always so. Most village history was oral and therefore easily misinterpreted or confused by the passage of time.

Because there was little or no written resource to refer to or a shared technical knowledge, it was easy to explain away events or occurrences as ‘magic’ or ‘sorcery’, particularly when there was animosity between the various groups in an immediate area.

Whilst an autopsy will provide immediate confirmation of a specific cause of death, without more widespread education, the question remains whether such initiatives on their own will rid the nation of sorcery among less literate people.

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Paul Oates

So where is the PNG leadership demonstrated by Ross when he had the responsibility to do so?

Public outcries by political leaders are all very well but Phillip has correctly presented the answer to this problem that seems to be rapidly increasing in rural PNG.

Who will now take national leadership in this issue now?

Sori tumas. Mi no harim ol lida ibin tokaut lo displa hevi? PM na Minista blo edukesion yu stap we a?

Philip Kai Morre

Dr Betty Koka is taking a good approach in educating the people to know the causes and effects of sicknesses.

However, believing in sorcery of all sorts is in the sub-conscious level of every individual person in PNG including educated people.

Early intervention programs educating the school age children would be better than educing the adults who will never discard their fixed belief system.

Also early medical knowledge on the causes and effects of diseases must be taught in schools to reduce the prevalence of sanguma and witchcraft.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)