My Photo
Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 02/2006

« At least I did try | Main | PNG one of world’s most ‘fragile’ nations says report »

05 December 2016


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Didn't someone else see cricket as an alternative to tribal warfare? Charles Abel at Kwato perhaps. he obviously hadn't watched Trobriand Islands' cricket

According to Francis West in his biography of Sir Hubert Murray, Murray stated in his book, Papua of Today, that he and his officers searched for substitutes for cannibalism, headhunting and tribal warfare. He considered that pig meat and pigs'heads would replace the first two and football would replace fighting.

However, that might be fine for the actual participants of a football match but what about the audience? Having lived in Port Moresby while the annual Papua versus New Guinea rugby league matches were played, I was nearly caught up in a riot at the end of one of these matches when the crowd exited into the streets of Boroko and started smashing up everything in sight.

Mike Carlton, the journalist, provided a classic description of rugby league and said it was a game played by a handful of northern English who keep coal in their bath, do strange things with ferrets, and race pigeons in their spare time.

I was once trapped at the top end of Fraser Island with a bunch of indigenous rangers during one of those State of Origin matches Richard and they tried to explain the intricacies of the game and the differences between league and union. Alas, it went in one ear and out the other.

I can claim a passing acquaintance with snooker in my misspent youth if that helps.

Well, well, well Phil. And here I was - as someone who earned a living writing and broadcasting sport for 35 years -- 10 of those in PNG - sure that you were a man of considerable knowledge.

Rugby league, the 13 a side game, is PNG's national sport. Huge emotions are stirred in PNG three times a year when the NSW vs. Qld State of Origin matches are played.

Rugby union is the hearty chaps/Twickers code played by teams of 15-a-side. It has a wider international appeal than league which started life as a code in the industrial north of the UK.

The AFL is the peak body of Australian Rules footy. As a South Australian you probably know that people mistakenly and constantly refer to the 18-a-side game as 'AFL'. What they actually mean is 'Aussie Rules.' The AFL is just the top grade in that sport.

Sport is war without the bullets-George Orwell

Rugby league in PNG is still misunderstood by many who support it; it can beget violence and I'm thrilled to know it has been used as a peace tool in Bena Bena area of EHP.

Yet paradoxically, it can be one of the few sports in the country that can unite our nation! Sounds foolish but true.

The Australian Rugby League and Australian government has for some time seen and talked about the potential the sport of rugby league has in doing a lot of good for the country, but no significant technical and managerial assistance has been provided to realise that potential.

Phil, The PNG folk who proudly represented their country at the Empire/ Commonweath Games in Perth in 1962 might not support some of your sentiments. Sadly most are now deceased.

Phil you may not believe this however I actually promoted the Bena Bena Peace Cup which was a rugby league comp in the Bena Bena area to promote peace among the warring clans out there.

I myself was very sceptical about using Rugby League in promoting peace however the day was a brilliant success.

We managed to bring Canberra Raiders on board through John Dixon of the Raiders who donated a large selection of equipment from the Raiders franchise which was distributed amongst the players.

I think it was probably the first time Rugby League has been used to create peace.

Did I say sport was 'evil' Ed?

I think I just said it was not my cup of tea. To each his own I say.

My next door neighbour looks great and her daughter looks even greater. My brother-in-law, on the other hand, has lately got crook knees. But, then again, so have I from all that walking I've done over my life, not least in PNG. I hope my next door neighbour's eventual arthritis is benign.

I guess with our obesity epidemic sport could be a good thing, participating rather than watching of course.

Digging a vegetable garden might help too.

Mission accomplished, Phil: you’ve provoked me.

Setting aside some of the obscenities of professional sports (outrageous player payments and transfer fees; drug-based performance enhancement and cheating; corruption on a global scale; ultra-violent tribalism), engagement and/or a more than passing interest in sport does more good than harm.

While inevitably promoting and supporting tribalism, both malignant and benign, amateur sports can instill desirable values and behaviours like teamwork, honesty, loyalty, self-discipline, diligence, respect for others, graciousness (in defeat and victory) and so on.

There are, also, the (sometime double-edged) ‘virtues’ of compliance with rules and obedience to authority generally (which are, also, the ultimate purpose of our education systems in any case).

And one should not overlook the obvious benefits for one’s general health, fitness and self-esteem: as a good friend once told me, going to the gym, running marathons and such have less to do with a desire for fitness than with promoting one’s self-esteem.

As you’ve noted yourself, involvement or merely an interest in sport acts as a social bond, allowing and reinforcing social interaction and engagement with others.

My own involvement in playing, refereeing and administering basketball in PNG enabled the establishment of connections and friendships with Papua New Guineans which would not have occurred otherwise and which continue to this day.

I realise, of course that I’ve said nothing that you (and other PNG Attitude readers) didn’t already know.

But it’s also worth remembering that, in the final analysis, sport is a force for good, not evil, regardless of your indifference and scorn.

Onya Phil. I totally agree.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)