My Photo
Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 02/2006

« The buga bolum thanksgiving ritual of the Mitnade people | Main | Stuart Inder: journalist who recorded the Pacific's transition »

08 February 2015


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

I am writing this to Bob Lawrence, the writer of this article. Firstly, I would like to pass on my condolences to Stuart Inder's family and friends.

My name is Sue Smales and I am the daughter of said Angus Smales in his article. I quote from Bob Lawrence "In October 1975, when Stuart retired as editor, another giant of Pacific journalism, long time Herald and Weekly Times Papua New Guinea correspondent, Angus Smales, moved to Sydney to take over the editorship."

I wish to set the facts straight about the times mentioned. I do not know when Stuart left PIM, but I do know that my father was in PNG up until the early 80s, (1981/82 from memory).I myself did not leave until 1983.

To say he left in 1975 is almost criminal to me as it wipes out many years of his very fine work as a journalist. I was a teenager and remember the days and nights of him being away travelling throughout the country following the election campaigns, particularly of the PANGU Pati.

Chief and then Prime Minister Sir Michael Somare often gave dad priority press for his tours as he trusted my father to give the facts.

Something my father taught me as an adult when I indulged in a bit of journalism myself, was to always get your facts right and to not give your own opinion. You are simply reporting he would say. (I find the opinion one a bit hard I have to admit) I am also not as good on grammar - the bane of my life.

Dad was awarded an Independence Medal and an MBE for his service to PNG as a journalist and for his unbiased and factual reporting.

I would like to thank Bob Lawrence for calling my father a giant of Pacific journalism, as I am very proud of his legacy to PNG and to journalism.

Nice tribute to a genuine nice guy. If it is not too late I have just one snippet you might add.

I was covering an election in Fiji in the early 1980s - it was the one where Four Corners had produced a program extremely critical of Ratu Sir Kamisese Mara and the Opposition parties had run off scores of copies of the program and played them all over the place during the election campaign.

Mara won but he was extremely angry with the foreign media.

We were all trying to get Mara to give us an interview after the results were known but he brushed us all off - including Stuart Inder.

Mara went into a lift in the Government building and all the rest of the media turned away.

I was standing with Stuart when the lift door opened again and Ratu Mara motioned to Stuart to join him and go up to his office for the only interview he would give to anyone who was not from Fiji.

Not to mention the fabulous covers, Martin, wonder how they'd go down today?

For those of us who study Pacific history and write of both the colonial days and the tumultuous times surrounding movements towards national independence, the long-defunct 'Pacific Islands Monthly' remains a rich and valuable archival resource.

The obituaries, personal profiles, gossip, local news items and even the passenger lists of ships and aircraft published by PIM enable historians to place expatriates and locations within the context of the period, not to mention allowing movements to be traced and verified.

PIM was, of course, essentially a magazine aimed at expatriates and their interests. The often illuminating articles and letters from old hands in the Pacific about local 'goings on' bring colour and texture to island life when compared with the content of the turgid bureaucratic files and newsletters produced by the colonial governments of the time.

Often, PIM brought about controversy by reporting events which didn't find the light of day in the official press in the islands themselves.

The 'Letters to the Editor' columns remain a great source of knowledge to researchers as planters, traders and other adventurers often used that space to take 'pot shots' at local bureaucracies over one issue or another.

Thank you Stuart and your team of journalists, stringers and contributors for the pleasure of years of reading and for leaving historians a wonderful archival resource. PIM tells of another Pacific, now past.

I've just blown the dust off the browning pages of my clippings folder that preserves some of the articles I wrote as a freelance journalist in PNG. My first piece in PIM appeared in the June 1972 issue (big story - 'Kieta Council moves its gallery') and followed a visit Stuart made to Bougainville, during which he invited me to contribute to the magazine each month.

Stuart was a very companionable and laid back character and I was delighted to be asked and appreciative of the remuneration, which I think was 10 cents a word.

Over the next few years I wrote under various noms de guerre - A Kieta Correspondent, A Bougainville Correspondent and A Port Moresby Correspondent - and eventually under my own name, which caused a minor fracas among some journalists at the National Broadcasting Commission where I was running policy and planning and they reckoned I should stick to that.

Managing a radio station in Sydney a few years later, I was a regular imbiber of claret and information at those convivial PIM monthly lunches in an upstairs room at the Occidental Hotel in York Street.

Indeed, it was there in early 1983 that I was called to the hotel phone to be told that Malcolm Fraser had just called a general election was on and that I should hot foot it to Labor Party headquarters to receive my instructions as the ALP candidate for Mackellar under our new leader Bob Hawke.

PIM was more than just a magazine. It was an institution. Its editors were fine journalists and people who couldn't help becoming your mates.

Stuart Inder's stewardship covered a critical period in the transition of the Pacific from colonisation to independence and it was a damn shame when the shiny bums of Collins Street decided this important publication was of no interest to them and should be permitted to wither and die.

I published my first article in the Pacific Islands Monthly in 1968 when Stuart was editor.

With his encouragement I developed a second life as a freelancer and branched out publishing articles and stories in other magazines and journals.

The only major I couldn't crack was the Reader's Digest, I just couldn't develop the blandness they required.

Those were the heydays of journalism and it was sad to see it all get swallowed up by the Internet.

The Pacific Islands Monthly was a victim of Rupert Murdoch, just as the Bulletin was a victim of James Packer. If it didn't make money it had to go, no matter its history, social relevance and quality.

Now that the money men rule the world we eat trash.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)