Sir Mekere Morauta, Leader of the PNG Opposition, speaking
in Parliament, has challenged the Somare Government over its putative carbon
trading activities.
He has expressed alarm at developments that had recently come
to light in relation to premature carbon trading, and unusual agreements with a
large number of companies to trade carbon on behalf of PNG “without proper
scrutiny and without regulatory policy or legislation in place”.
“If we are not careful, cowboys operating behind the
scenes, using our name and wearing our cloak, will reap the lion’s share of
carbon revenue,” Sir Mekere said.
“It appears that the Prime Minister and his henchmen,
including the Minister for Planning and more recently the Director of the
Office of Climate Change, have been hawking these potential assets around the
world to all and sundry”.
Sir Mekere said one firm appointed by the government, Climate
Assist (PNG), is a one dollar company based in Rockhampton with its sole
director, Mr Gregory Corby, providing an address in Toowoomba.
“Another Australian company, Carbon Planet, last year advanced
the Office of Climate Change $1.2 million,” he said. “As with Climate Assist, the
Opposition wonders what connections Carbon Planet and its Chairman, Mr Jim
Johnson have with the Prime Minister or the Prime Minister’s associates.”
“A close relative of the Prime Minister is involved with yet
another company, Pacific Carbon,” he said. “The media alleges the PM’s relative
has been urging people in East Sepik to sign
away rights to land for trading carbon to this company.
“We also wonder why, when questioned about this payment by
an AAP reporter, Mr Johnson would say so defensively: ‘I am not explaining at
all. I am not having this conversation’.
Sir Mekere went on to say that these three cases were not
the only examples of premature carbon trading conducted by the PNG government.
“Apparently last year, the Office of Climate Change authorized
a Swiss based broker, South Pole Carbon Asset Management, to market 1 million
tonnes of avoided carbon dioxide emission per annum from a PNG logging project
based in the Sepik."
He also revealed that Macquarie Bank is the latest company
to want to jump on the bandwagon.
“Macquarie Bank has been in discussions with the Office of
Climate Change, offering to broker carbon trade deals and retain 15% of profits,”
he said. “If the voluntary carbon market turns out to be worth billions of
dollars in the next couple of years, as predicted by a number of players, the
Bank’s 15% would be very handsome income indeed.”
“It is obvious that the whole situation in relation to
carbon trading in our country is a complete and utter mess,” Sir Mekere
concluded. “Instead of developing an appropriate policy and legal framework that
ensures protection of the interests of landowners and the state, the Prime
Minister, Ministers and the staff of the Office of Climate Change have been
criss-crossing the globe, appointing ‘brokers’ on who knows what terms, and
basically selling people’s and national assets at whim.
“If the funds have not been paid to Consolidated Revenue, we
want to know how are they being accounted, and what authority the Office of
Climate Change has to raise or to spend these funds.
“Above all, we want to know why the Government is
promoting all these deals, when there is no regulatory policy or legislation
for carbon trading in PNG."
Twixt and ‘tween - where from here for PNG?
"The Pacific region is seriously off track to achieve the Millennium Development Goals by 2015. The people of the Pacific expect us all, donors and Pacific island governments alike, to do much better" - Bob McMullan MP, Parliamentary Secretary for International Development Assistance
Before one can work out a solution, the problem must be defined. So what’s the problem here? If, as Bob McMullan believes, the region is ‘off track’, where’s the track? It seems that the map’s been lost.
When we arrived in PNG in the sixties, we were told it was a nation of villages. At the time, that was true. So what changed?
Rudyard Kipling had a unique gift for describingIndia .
But his gift lay beyond description. He understood it as ordinary people saw
it. In his fable Betwixt and Between,
Kipling depicts a group of animals talking around a campfire.
First, Elephant, talking first because he’s the biggest. “I carry the heavy howitzers of the. Without them, the Army can’t win the battle. Being very intelligent, as soon as I hear gunfire I won't go on.”
“I carry the pack loads over dry deserts,” says Camel, “The Army can’t fight without food and supplies. Still, we’re not much help when the fighting starts,” she confesses."
Mule observes that, while people think he’s inherently stubborn, “we mules carry the guns and supplies and are often casualties of war. But we can break our ropes and escape.”
Charger speaks up. “I carry the Officer into battle at a mad dash and often wind up a casualty myself.”
"Oh, well," says Bullock, "we’re degraded and ignored. We take the guns from the rear, and carry them to the front, slowly I admit. But we don't run away when fighting starts and loyally die in our yokes and traces. No one thinks much about it but, without us, the Army couldn't win its battles. We really are betwixt and between.”
After World War II the Pacific was never the same. The tide of war swept much away. The lament of the Marshall Islanders centres on the contradiction of living on the beneficence of theUS , which fought
the Japanese In these islands and, after victory, never left. The islanders
express a desire to return to their traditional life but can't work out how to
do it.
This is a microcosm of the basic dilemma facing Pacific nations today. Can a village way of life be transposed into a modern government? There are precious few examples where it has happened.
When I arrived in PNG, I was told, as many of you were, that we were agents of change. What we did in the sixties was to govern without changing rural PNG village culture. To those who came later, it seemed an easy act to follow. All you needed, it seemed, were an education, the right clothes, a modern house and a car, and you could govern.
So we come to the nub. A nation is not a village and cannot be governed using traditional methods. Leaders need to evolve who can operate at another level.
Overseas aid does not necessarily help this. It can become addictive. It can detract from the perpetual political (and personal) problem of never having enough resources to do what you want.
What is required is a new approach. Bob McMullan is correct when he says the 'Pacific is off track'. But where’s the track? PNG does not lack educated and able people who can govern. It seems the problem is that these potential leaders are not learning to lead. They are ‘betwixt and between’.
Posted at 04:43 AM in Commentariat, News | Permalink | Comments (1)