My Photo
Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 02/2006

« 'Disgraceful' PNG government trashes its health system | Main | PNG’s new high commissioner meets teacher after 44 years »

13 February 2018

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Had the Melanesians invented ships prior to the Greco-Romans, the West could have believed in Sanguma today.

Chris and Phil - The discourse surrounding this phenomenon and the debate it can generate can take us in all sorts of directions.

I am from a province in this country, where both belief in sanguma or withcraft are pervasive, and the reactions to them from the communities have been destructive and fatal for those accused to be agents or practicing them.

Even educated elites have been subdued by this belief that they refuse to go back to their communities of origin and contribute meaningfully.

I have a far more detailed response that I intend to share with readers of this blog at a later time soon.
_______

Looking forward to that John - KJ

Sanguma, witchcraft, satan or whoever is unseen and who is believed to be causing all the problems in the world is psychological garbage.

Non empirical means of explaining sickness and death has no scientific proof. There is no cause and effect or known etiology of explaining the causes of sicknesses and death.

The Melanesian world view or philosophy of personalism and spiritualism is the solo basis of believing in sanguma and witchcraft. It's in the sub-conscious of every person who believes in sanguma - even car accidents or deaths by natural disaster are attributed to sanguma.

We cannot believe in conspiracy theories or non-existent forces as real and can make something happen.

Para-psychology and telepathy do exist but have no relationship with witchcraft or sanguma.

PS: That guy in the picture looks familiar, I'm sure I've seen him in PNG somewhere. Maybe in the Haus Tambaran?

A lot of Australian Aboriginal groups rationalise their dual beliefs in Christianity and the so-called 'Dreaming' by claiming that God invented or gave them the Dreaming.

In a similar sense you could rationalise sanguma as an invention or gift of God's great nemesis, Satan.

Dreaming is good, therefore it must have come from God.

Sanguma is bad, therefore it must have come from Satan.

I suspect however, like most politicians know, that to promulgate a particular idea it is always handy to have an enemy.

Capitalism has Communism or Socialism.

God has Satan.

For God to sound believable it is necessary to have Satan.

I was raised as a Scottish Presbyterian, which preached a rather austere version of Christianity.

My parents insisted that I go to church each Sunday. This was odd because my father had abandoned his religious beliefs during World War 2 and my mother never showed the slightest interest is resuming her association with the even more austere Methodist church.

Like most kids, I rather uncritically accepted Christian dogma, including all the magical bits like miracles and the resurrection. My child's mind could not readily distinguish between fact and fiction, especially as it was adults who were earnestly inculcating me with "the truth" about God.

Many years later, after educating myself a bit more about the real world, I came to understand that Christianity and all other religions require that adherents accept the utterly implausible and, sometimes, obviously impossible, as true.

I also came to understand how religion had started as a way of explaining the unexplainable before slowing transmogrifying into a means by which socio-economic elites exerted both secular and moral power.

In short, I came to my current understanding of religion as an elaborate hoax or fraud, which bears as much relation to the truth as does the theology described in Tolkien's "Lord of the Rings" or George Lucas's invention of "the force" as depicted in the Star Wars movies.

Unhappily, a legacy of European imperialism has been the spread of Christian beliefs amongst people whose perfectly satisfactory animist beliefs had served them well (or at least no less badly) over the millennia.

In PNG, I think that the indigenous population were able to neatly integrate their old belief system with the new one being urged upon them by Christian missionaries. This included the notion of Satan.

This notion is, even under the most cursory analysis, highly suspect. Somehow, Christian dogma succeeds in reconciling the existence of an omniscient and omnipotent creator with his supposed nemesis, the proverbial fallen angel.

Basically, Satan is a former employee sacked for theological policy infringements who has set up another religion and constantly seeks to poach customers (or their souls) from God.

God's police, in the form of witch hunters like the infamous Inquisition, devoted centuries to hunting down Satan's adherents. Mostly, the Satanic fiends have proved to be older, "wise" women.

Oddly, strapping young men armed with swords or spears don't figure much in witch hunting lore.

The wisdom of supposed witches was almost invariably related to natural phenomena like traditional medicines, fertility and child birth. This caused discomfort to a church which insisted on supernatural explanations for such things.

Over the centuries many entirely innocent women have been cruelly murdered for simply being older or possessing knowledge that offended religious orthodoxy.

Unhappily, this sort of satanic nonsense plays well with those who are disposed to belief in so called "black magic". This is one reason why this pernicious belief system has persisted into the modern era in places like PNG and, indeed, in some very dark corners of Australian society too.

Religion has a lot to answer for here. By promoting supernatural beliefs which are central to its dogma it necessarily provides implicit support and justification for other supernatural belief systems.

There is no plausible way for the church in PNG or anywhere else to deny one set of supernatural beliefs while promoting another. Once you use magic to justify faith, there is no escape clause that allows you to deny the faith of others which is justified on the same irrational basis.

This is one reason why I have chosen to consciously and determinedly reject all religion for the bunkum and humbug that it truly is.

I prefer to put my faith in science which, although it will certainly never allow me or anyone else to truly know all the secrets of the universe, offers the prospect of having at least a hazy idea about how this amazingly complex reality actually works.

I'll never see a quark or gluon or boson but at least my belief in their existence is based upon some hard science, not a fantasy made up eons ago to explain the then unexplainable.

In Melanesian society, the evil of sanguma (supernatural spells) did exist for various purposes. When you do a baseline study on Melanesia sanguma you appreciate the complete nature of the myth. Otherwise, you are on the bandwagon of someone’s apprehension or opinion of the myth.

In Melanesia, and PNG in particular, the myth of sanguma takes many forms and the evil spell exists to serve specific purposes.

For example, in Chimbu, what they call in the local Kuman dialect, ‘kumkwibo or kumo’ is believed to cause untimely deaths of people.

Other evil spells (gilgia) cannot cause death but make someone become destitute for life or cause diminished prospects in life or psychological problems.

In coastal PNG like Sepik, Papua or the Islands, and in the Tari basin, there is magic people are thought to possess which exists for specific purposes in society.

You would hardly believe your eyes when a Koari (Papua) man can conjure up a supernatural power to mend a seriously broken collar or rib bone in cases where a medical doctor cannot do much.

Different evil spells existed for different purposes in Melanesian society for centuries.

The Western hegemony brought to Melanesia the existence of Satan and his evil spell is synonymous to sanguma or gilgia as practiced in PNG.

What we read in the bible about Satan and his work is identical to what was practised in Melanesia by certain people. Therefore, you often hear people talking about sorcery as ‘possession of satanic power’.

You need a baseline study of sanguma to understand its different types, how it exists, how the different evil spells work and the pros and cons of it.

Without such, your knowledge of sanguma or sorcery in PNG and Melanesia is very limited.

Believing in things they've never seen and which defy logic seems to be a common human trait.

As you say, if people are expected to believe in a Christian god they should be allowed to believe in something as similarly ethereal as sorcery.

That both beliefs have led to great suffering is indisputable. On that basis alone you would have expected people to have ditched both beliefs. Unfortunately humans are also generally stupid and haven't done so.

Whoever made up either yarn in the first place must be rolling with laughter. Or maybe they are appalled at what their lies have caused.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)