My Photo
Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 02/2006

« Women’s rugby league's power for change in PNG | Main | Kumuls can knock England out of world cup says Paul Aiton »

16 November 2017

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Mr. Allen has been found, or he showed up, alive and well.

He denied international media over allegation of a set-up, and said there were no such things when talking to the Tourism Promotion Authority.

He sounds like a gentleman enough!

He now needs to get back to those international media and tell his story to put his case to rest, once and for all.

I like the first paragraph Peter.

"An anthropologist, an explorer and a tourist walk into a bar. They’re each clutching a spear. The anthropologist describes how it was presented to her on her seventh fieldwork season by the elders of the tribe. The explorer regales them with the tale of how he won the spear upon completing an initiation challenge the tribe had set for him, filmed for a documentary. The tourist explains that he paid $10 for his at the market, and needs to get back now otherwise the cruise ship will leave without him …"

This is an interesting article about the inherent ethical dilemmas facing anthropologists, explorers and tourists.

And of course people are not objective subjects like rocks or birds. It is only through a sharing of language, experience and culture that we can come to understand each other.

It’s perhaps as patriarchal – with all the echoes of colonial-era racism – to suggest that it’s for “us” to decide what is or isn’t ok for “them”.

Maybe the remote Papua New Guinean tribe want to welcome the same white guy who last showed up thirty years ago. Maybe once-remote peoples see holidaying visitors as a key revenue stream for their 21st-century lives.

And maybe the adventurous anthropologist with tenure in mind is no more or less self-interested than the tourist who wants an exotic selfie for instagram, or the explorer who wants another yarn to tell.

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/nov/23/explorers-anthropologists-tourists-benedict-allen

Christopher Albert just told me.....I met him on his visit this year, about a 6 -8 weeks ago. I've forgotten the date. So he came with a group of British Tourists and he was the leader of the group. I am working with Sepik Adventure Tours and i had to take them out to Pagwi for their tour of the Sepik. They came back 3 days later and went to Tufi and he told me that he will be returning on a Wednesday that was like 5 days later and he asked if i can help to organize a car to use for about an hour to shop for bushknives and other material things to go to a remote area somewhere along the Sepik borders via a hired helicopter. And that was the last time i talked to him.

If the Daily Mail needs a guide to track down this lost adventurer in Mt Hagen it should look no further Ireland. Knock on the door and ask for Fr Gary Roche.

From today's Daily Mail in the UK:

"(The missing man) was spotted by tribal chiefs (yep, chiefs no less) near an airstrip in PNG's remote Enga Province after failing ... to find the last people on the planet who have no contact with the outside world."

Where are they hiding, these phantoms of the jungle? Perhaps he should have googled it to find out?

And:

"Mr Allen was eventually tracked down to Mount Hagen, one of the most remote mountains in the world."

Wow, found at remotest Mount Hagen (population 46,256 in 2013). Perhaps one of Air New Guinea's regular jet flights spotted him whilst coming into land?

I think that I sense a book deal and associated documentary coming on, in which Mr Allen vividly recounts his desperate 3 week journey in the wilds of PNG, pursued be ravening cannibals and afflicted by awful tropical diseases, leeches, insects, etc.

Shows what happens if you leave your iPhone and GPS at home, eh?

Guardian today has a critical comment by Charlie Brinkhurst-Cuff on Benedict Allen that concludes by saying:

"White men such as Benedict Allen should cease their meaningless, problematic 'explorations' and focus instead on the ways they can counter the privileges they inhabit, at home and abroad."

Another publicity stunt? Like the reality show couple who were supposedly held up on the Kokoda track the other year and found to be frauds?

Kokoda track tour operator Charlie Lynn said things "just didn't add up" with the story of his disappearance.

"I thought 'Here we go again, we've got another British explorer or reality star wannabe going to Papua New Guinea to try and generate a sensational story, using the thing of remote jungles and crocodile infestation and cannibals and getting lost and then later on getting found'," Mr Lynn said.

"He's supposedly an experienced explorer, he's been there before, but to go into a remote area of Papua New Guinea without a GPS; and apparently he didn't make any plans for his own evacuation if he needed it, and he didn't let anybody know where he was going.

Mr Lynn said the story fuelled negative perceptions of the country in the international media.

"I've got to say Papua New Guinea don't help themselves a lot but they're the victims in these scams, if you like, where people come in and they make out they're backward jungle cannibals living in remote tribal areas and so forth," he said.

"It's just grist to the mill for a sensationalist newspaper report and it certainly gets international attention."

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-11-17/british-explorer-lost-in-png-criticised-for-lack-of-preparation/9163516

Men are fond of these:
*being famous
*being glorified
*legacy making
*being praised
*making history
By the unfolding of things, this scenario to have been framed just to achieve one of the above.
Front page of today's National Paper [17th November 2017] stated, 'Missing British Explorer 'Spotted'

Larim pukpuk kaikaim em.

The Guardian reporting that this man has been found "alive and well" but still in a remote area. "Allen, 57, has spotted near an airstrip and has asked to be rescued, according to reports." All going as planned ???

I just found this update in today's Guardian.....The explorer who went missing in the Papua New Guinean jungle has been found alive and well and has asked for a rescue party to be sent to pick him up, it has been reported.

Benedict Allen, who has made programmes for the BBC, had gone travelling in an attempt to find the Yaifo tribe, one of the few left in the world that has little to no contact with outsiders and whom he first met 30 years ago.

The BBC’s security correspondent, Frank Gardner, who met up with Allen just before he left and who sought to publicise the 57-year-old’s disappearance after he missed a planned flight home, said his friend had been sighted.

Speaking on BBC Breakfast on Thursday, Gardner said: “He has been sighted alive and well near a remote airstrip in Papua New Guinea having trekked vast distances. He has requested rescue and efforts are under way to get him out. This is only a reported sighting, but it is the second sighting and it’s a tribal commission that has been looking for him and they have reported him in. So unless they have got it horribly wrong, and I’m not aware of any other lost British explorers in that part of Papua New Guinea, Benedict Allen is safe and well.”

A spokeswoman for Jo Sarsby Management, Allen’s agent, told the Guardian it is believed he was waiting at an airstrip in the country’s Hewa region.

She said it was understood the airstrip was not accessible by road and that it is hoped that a helicopter would be sent on Friday.

Later, Gardner reported that Allen was still at risk because he is “marooned” on an airstrip cut off by road after tribal fighting.

................

One of my Sepik wantoks will ring up tomorrow to find out what is going on.

Yes Phil. Not only does he sound annoying, but I would say a very careless man indeed or an attention seeker, trying to create a scene.

Someone or the local police should simply bundle him up and send him to Port Moresby, from where he can be sent on his way!

He must never be allowed into the country again.

We are tired of "attention seekers" already.

The local indigenous people have copped a hammering of their image internationally for all the wrong reasons.

No one in PNG, even in the remotest corner is completely cut of from modernisation. A preplanned adventure story for the one who commissioned this trip, I guess.

from Paul Mateos...

I recall Benedict,He was staying in Inn Wewak Boutique Hotel when I was asked by my dad (Mateos Alois) to pick him up and help him do his shopping for his trip to the Sepik River at the end of last month. He was on his private tour to a very remote part of the Sepik. He said he was going to Bisorio by a chopper. I asked him how long he'll be out there and he said for 13 days..with his camera he took videos of the whole shopping trip. He bought 2 bales of rice,a dozen of tuna cans,corned beef,sackets of coffee,biscuits,blankets,mosquito nets,Bush knives,water containers,etc..I believe he is not missing but must be out of communications range and got stranded..

The so-called Yaifo are by no means isolated. They have access to mobile phones and lots of other modern technology.

Hopefully one of them will give the cops a buzz and ask them to get rid of this annoying man.

Another Alby Mangels living on Mars Bars awaiting an exclusive formulaic interview with an alleged journalist from the Channel 9 Today program

I hate to sound cynical but this story has all the elements of a set up.

When Mr Allen reappears, and he will, there will be headlines, "Intrepid explorer escapes from remote headhunter tribe.

It will elaborate his run in with drug dealers and the terrors of being lost in the jungle without food or water, terrorised by wild pigs, no phone communication etc.

The statements from his sister all seem to carry elements of a Bear Grylls character and potential elements of a plot. A great promotional story if he is about to release a book or make a dramatic presentation to the Royal Geological society.

And by the way, he will have had the foresight to return to civilisation with rolls of wild film footage of his capture/adventure.

By the way, a warning to all dogs in the Yaifo area, avoid a hungry man!

If I am wrong I will most happily apologise for my cynicism!

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)