My Photo
Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 02/2006

« The egocentric leader | Main | Rain is not the end of PNG's drought, merely the next phase »

23 January 2016


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

More indiscretions by the couple surfaced in the paper today while they were on the trek....

I can still remember the uproar after the Gotcha headline on the Sun front page following the sinking of the ARA General Belgrano in the 1982 Falklands War.

This was followed by the false accusations immediately after the Hillsborough Stadium disaster in 1989.

It really is a grubby paper which targets the trailer park trash and tattoos to teeth ratio brigade in the UK. It is littered with photographs of soft pornography because most of its readers are illiterate.

Good on you my friends. Please let the world know that Yes there are rape cases here, law and order corruption and other problems that any country is facing right now...except cannibals!

And thank you Dr Nelson.

There is no excuse for the alleged rape. Those who are found guilty will face the full force of the law.

But people with preconceived notions about who or what we are, and only enter the country for their personal glory and destroy us should stay in their own countries!

The reporter of the UK Sun Tabloid or whatever should go back to school and learn his/her Geography.
We are living in the 21st century. There are no cannibals in PNG.

Thank you so much, Genevieve, for your heart warming report which is an entirely authentic information about Kokoda and its beautiful environs.

Charlie Lynn's report says it all: a disgraceful and defamatory fraud. I wonder if The Sun will publish the truth and whether the Police will seek the extradition of the real offenders in this case?

Spot on, Raymond. A most disgraceful performance by two con artists.

This couple should be brought back and investigated properly by relevant authorities because two youths were arrested as a result of their claim of being attacked.

If it is a publicity stunt, they should be arrested and charged for defamation of the local people and the historical relevance of the Kokoda Track as well as court fined for causing international disrepute to the historical significance of the Kokoda Track as a war memorial pilgrim route and creating a crisis for our fledging tourism industry in PNG.

What makes me even more suspicious is the name of the American woman. Michelle Clemens. Mark Twain anyone? Known for his stunts and tall stories.

I foolishly went in search of the original story. It is far worse than any nonsense I have seen written about PNG. Here's a sample...

"A COUPLE last night spoke of their fears of being eaten by spear-waving tribesmen after they were captured while trekking in a jungle known for cannibalism.

Brit Matthew Iovane and American girlfriend Michelle Clemens, both 31, had been on the dream trip to Papua New Guinea when they were pounced on by painted men on Monday.

Two natives with machetes beat and stripped the terrified pair before blindfolding them and leading them into the jungle.

The couple said the tribesmen, one of whom wore a mask made from feathers and vines, were so primitive that they communicated in grunts.

But they said they knew enough English to issue the chilling warning: “We will kill you.”

But the key is this - "Brand consultant Matthew, who appeared in Channel 4 survival show Shipwrecked, was brutally beaten when the pair tried to escape."

Yep, it's a perverted publicity stunt for a TV show. I won't link to the story, but needless to say it is rife with descriptions of cannibals, torture and primitive natives, complete with a photo of Huli wigmen for some reason.

It is straight out of the pages of a GA Henty story. No, he reveals some narrative merit, the Sun is just plain s***.

Read Charlie Lynn's first rate analysis of the incident here. The conclusion is inescapable - it was an exploitative and reckless publicity stunt - KJ

I was stationed at Kokoda as a Kiap during 1972/73.

At that time there were no organised tours across the Kokoda Track but a few intrepid individuals used to walk it on their own or in very small groups. These walkers had to be entirely self sufficient.

I think that the people living along the track tended to view these early walkers with a sense of bemusement: why on earth would anyone want to make the arduous trek between Moresby and Kokoda unless urgent pressing necessity required it?

Despite this, they treated the walkers courteously. There were no reported incidents of theft, assault or intimidation (let alone cannibalism) during my time at Kokoda nor, so far as I know, before that time.

I strongly endorse Dr Nelson's comments on the general habits and disposition of the Koiari and Orokaiva people living along the track.

I do not know the truth about the alleged attacks but, if it occurred as reported, it is the action of a few criminal idiots and not at all representative of the outlook or disposition of the local people.

As Dr Nelson rightly points out, the local people rely upon the walking "industry" as one of their few reliable sources of cash income and would certainly not wish to jeopardise this. Their eager cooperation with the RPNGC is clear testimony to their concern about the potential adverse effect this incident could have upon tourism.

The Sun's risible and irresponsible reporting is deplorable but typical of that type of rag: anything for a good story, even if this requires making up some spurious "facts" to give readers a more entertaining experience.

I just hope that Dr Nelson can get a right of reply in this case although I fear that The Sun will have now "moved on", as they say, to other stories.

It may be of some slight comfort to her that, in an age where the average reader's attention span is now measured in nano-seconds, the collateral damage in this case will probably be insignificant.

Dr Nelson, without prejudice, I suggest approaching the Australian Federal Police (whose intelligence network is very wide) to track down these two walkers with a view to answering a charge of "making a false statement" (or closest to that).

It does seem odd, as others have commented in various fora, that the clothing, footwear and baggage they were carrying on the medivac flight seemed to be in good order, and they seemed to be in high spirits.

I am sure the AFP or AusGOV would be willing to help in this case.

Australia has a vested and emotional interest in the Kokoda Track, it being a shrine for both Aussie soldiers and their PNG counterparts.

Dr Nelson, I wouldn't take anything that appears in the Sun seriously, apart from it showing the ignorance, bigotry and racism that pervades Rupert Murdoch's publications.

It is the worst of the worst and employs a vile racist, Katie Hopkins, as one of its 'writers' who has been the subject of many complaints.

Then of course there was the phone hacking scandal in which the Sun featured prominently. Its 'journalism' also includes photos of naked women on page 3 of every issue.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)