My Photo
Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 02/2006

« Going Nuts, the PNG Way | Main | Protest »

09 July 2014

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

I think the Education Department has put out a policy to deal with student behaviour ... what is it called Behaviour Management Policy?

Agnes - you have an ally here in Australia, Kevin Donnelly, who is currently reviewing the school curriculum for the Abbott government.

"Kevin Donnelly, has told of the “very effective” approach of his former physical education teacher who took misbehaving students aside and dared them to “throw the first punch”.

In a radio interview about behaviour management, Donnelly voiced support for the use of corporal punishment if the school community was in favour of it."

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jul/15/corporal-punishment-schools-kevin-donnelly

In Melanesian society with diverse cultures and norms, corporal punishment is best to nurture students in this more hostile environment.

It can foster a fear amongst students to surrender their bad behaviour to learning.

Fear is the beginning of wisdom and understanding and the moral values of a learner.

Our forefathers nurtured our fathers in a cruel manner to impart the best wisdom of manhood and it was suitable for a Melanesian society and environment.

Today PNG is still a Melanesian society, therefore we should execute corporal punishment in PNG schools again.

I suggest taking a breath and looking at some of the professional research.

http://www.endcorporalpunishment.org/pages/pdfs/Summary%20of%20research%20on%20the%20effects%20of%20corporal%20punishment%20April%202013.pdf

My own view is that introducing institutionalised violence into a community with many other problems with violent behaviour is not a good idea.

A pat on the back is good for children provided it is given often enough and low enough. My father's saying.

Seriously, the family unit is the catalyst, not the schools. Set the correct example at home and the classroom discipline will follow.

My parents were my mentors and if I got a smack at school, and went home and complained about it, I got another one.

Get the respect back to the family unit. Our parents are our mentors.

Tanya well said.

The family is the elemental unit. If parents play their part in enforcing discipline at home then it will have an impact.

If the father is a drunk and the mother a gambler, then this will be a challenging situation because the child will be in one word WILD.

Community development and welfare (national body as well as the provincial offices) in theory is suppose to do this job but that is not the case in PNG.

If parents seriously take their parental roles and duties, there will be no need for corporal punishment in schools.

Instead of addressing a symptom of a broken society at the school level, why not we work with families, address their challenges, give them information on how to become better parents so that they become good role models to their children.

After all, parents have more influence on how a child turns out in the future.

In light of international and domestic laws on child protection, using corporal punishment is or will to a certain degree be considered as child abuse.

On top of that PNG's department of foreign affairs and most democratic countries preach about promoting human rights in their foreign policy. Such a move suggested by the author is not in the ideological/cultural interest (category of national interest) of the nation.

Better to use a carrot instead of a stick.

A good debate.

DWU is working on the Bachelor of Primary Education curriculum as we speak. The debate is whether to teach ethics in primary level or not. Hope to read the program specification document in the coming months to see the future of primary education.

I join Bina in calling for creativity from the teachers. We want to progress and not to regress. When one is innovative and creative by using the status quo to their benefit then they can influence behavioural change in students.

Comparing Australia with PNG like what the author did is a bit naive. Sometimes we expect too much from PNG but we have to understand that PNG is a developing country. We are following our own evolutionary path which is very different to Australia and other Western countries. The context in PNG is very different.

Nothing to do with re-instating corporal punishment in schools, it's you and the govt who are not doing your best for the kids to archive quality education. Some schools in the country are well disciplined because they don't mark around with kids and schools rules, that's means how effect you deal with discipline in the school. Example catholic schools.
You sound pretty funny when you say "they have been fed with garbage from this Western education system and lack skills, knowledge and attitudes to meet their real needs". Of course one these garbage is corporal punishment yes, it was introduced into school back in the days by westerners, also you can't compare Australia to PNG regarding school quality of course it is western country, if you want to get quality education like australia as you stated the only way is to establish more effective school programs in schools. I am sorry but i had to say this western kids are well manned and discipline 95% better than us.
Thanks and God bless you with your effort and hope to re-introduction of corporal punishment in schools.

One of the best things in school when I was going during those 'lauto'times was a box of SRA readers. these boxes of self reading and assessment boxes had a tonne of short stories and question and answer sheet where you could do and tick it yourself and then plot the progress on a chart on the classroom wall.
this was the best discipline in school. if the teacher was not around,the class rushed for this box.
There were always things to do in the classroom so there were less fighting in the classroom.
Todays teachers leave the classroom with nothing like that in place. I have asked the missus who is a teacher if she has seen any SRA boxes and she says there is nothing around. She's been a primary school teacher for a long time now.
Students ought to look forward to coming to school. It should not be a monotonous compulsion to stay away from the boredom of the house or the unadventurous village or settlement.
This calls for teachers to be innovative and to do teaching outside of the box. Setting work out on the blackboard and asking children to copy straight into the books will not help in the classroom discipline. it will lead to issues outside of the classroom and onto the streets.
One innovative that is happening now is schools are allowing adults to return to classrooms eg Asaroka in the Eastern highlands. these adults should be immediately be given leadership roles in the classrooms as they come with a yearning to learn. I am told that the one at Asaroka is an ex LLG council president who was frustrated at having others do his work so that now he is doing it tough with four of his children in the school, a couple in the same grade. The student's will learn from his desire to learn. There are other senior citizenry in the school there too.
No, reintroducing corporal punishment wont work, try teacher innovation to motivate students learning. it does not necessarily have to be e-learning only as some schools are now doing.

You're not going far enough Agnes.

Introduce capital punishment into the schools.

That will make the little buggers learn.

Reminds us of the Outcome-Based Education controversy fostered by critic Corney Alone.

The systemic failure of years of misapplied unproductive philosophy has created road blocks in the production line.

I think it a further miscalculation to assume corporal punishment will do any more than legitimise the frustrated teacher's attempts to control an unruly and disenfranchised student body.

The country's authoritarian role models; police, are themselves contributors to disorder via their oft reported episodes of cruel and unusual behaviour.

Far better,I believe, to identify and categorise the problem issues and areas with a view to re-establishing remedial procedures designed to foster and promote literacy and numeracy.

Combine those efforts with further increase to economic stimulus in rural areas to inspire hope in the future of local industry or agriculture etc to at least offer the promise of sustenance.

This might be a means of slowing the tendency to migrate to urban fringe settlements that often become ghettos.

This is a step backward. How is corporal punishment going to be implemented? How is it addressing the underlying issues?

Should we not just start by financing the education system properly? 2% GDP to primary, 2% to secondary, and 2% to tertiary education? Costa Rica, for example, has done this for decades and literacy rates are now close to 100%.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.