My Photo
Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 02/2006

« The fight for land rages in Papua New Guinea | Main | Education in PNG: horror-child of Australian left ideology »

24 February 2013

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Not just PNG, all the Melanesian countries are suffering from the destruction of our traditional worldviews and value systems.

Our defence mechanisms for our very own existence, that have been passed down through our generations, are being destroyed or destructed by the coming of the Europeans and Asians.

We are now experiencing the dark ages in this 21st century. Colliding worldviews, cultures, fashions, and lifestyles coincide with what is now cultural genocide. It is like taking the fresh water fish out and replacing them into salt water and expecting them to survive.

I am sorry to say this but it seem that all of us are going to just die out, some by force and others by disease and sickness and this is actually happening in West Papua right now. We are loosing too many young, good men and women.

We are struggling hard, as we move away from our traditional system, and also struggling hard to adopt the modern system.

The so called" modern government, constitution, democracy or Westminster’s justice system, are strange things that have been forced down on us and it is not working.

We need and want to return to our tradition way of life, but the force of the modernity and globalization is so strong that it is sucking us into some kind of scary hurricane and with that we are loosing our sense of direction.

Christianity is loosing its validity; the simple message of the Kingdom of Heaven demonstrated by the Jewish itinerant preacher Yeshua 2,000 years ago has now been hijacked by the Christian mafia both within the churches and in politics.

I see the darkness covering the whole island of New Guinea. I see the ancient people of Melanesian becoming slave in our own land.

But at the same time I see hope. This hope must start from you, I and us. It is an individual inner awakening and transformation that will give hope to this dying culture and disillusioned human race.

The salvation of the New Guinea Island starts from you, I and us. Time to start waking up now and we might see things a lot clearer.

In whatever shape or form of education that we are trying to promote, the education itself is not the issue here, but the real issue, is what type of education and what type of information that needs to be taught in that education system.

As an Indigenous Melanesian living in the Western world for so long, I think that the gigantic "self indulge ship" of Western civilization is sinking and the Asians are making the same mistake by jumping into this sinking ship.

How about us? Can we go back to our tradition or join this sinking ship or is there a middle (hybrid) way to save our people and land. That's the challenge.

No educated person can deny that. Education has to be the key factor, in the lack of understanding some of the critical aspects of life today.

Today many children are not educated because of reason unexplanable,upon the due to failures of one and many, should I be not so straightforward.

How could one talk about a bright changing PNG when one has never set eyes upon the very poor. Who will bring the service. Who?

I have seen what is remote and when this basic service is going. No man is an island.

Thanks Joe for the challenge. Yes, we all have roles to play in developing Papua New Guinea either through education, sports, etc.

Thanks for the nice comments.

While education is the most important tool that can be used to minimize most of the social issues in PNG, there are few other ways which most you have mentioned in your comments.

So where can we start? Can we continue reading and writing philosophy by philosophy and ideas by ideas? Or can we stop educating people because they will buy weapons etc..?

You, the PNGean reader to this site, must do something now or we will have no one to blame in the next 30 years. Well, pen is mightier than sword, action speaks louder than words on the other hand.

As Margaret Mead once said "Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, concerned citizens can change world" We can change PNG.

Why dont we practice what we write on PNG Attitude and most others websites, blogs and medias. Or are we continue to blame our leaders for not intervening in social issues like tribal fight etc?

Lets start small whether in education, family, church, etc and see how far we go in the next few decades.. One man can make difference and it can happen in your society.

Sophisticated philosophical terms and constructive articles doesn't mean anything at all if it is not put into practice.

It is right that we need bright and intelligent elites to lead the society in positive manner that all of us will have the free will to move around without any social problems like the pick-pocketing issue.

Good topic Mr Joe Wasia, I do agree with the title 'Better education will tackle social issues in PNG'.

I personnaly agree with you about this social issue in our societies. It seems like some village educated people are underestimating themselves, and that some of the top shot educated elites are also part of that problem.

Anyway, you also gave the percentage of about 70% who are living in rural areas with no proper education. I think and feel for them. It is the government's task to provide services to those people.

Well said Phil.

Social issues and problems are connected in so many ways

If you educate someone you also build up their expectations.

People with a good education expect to get a good job. Unfortunately there aren't currently enough good jobs to go around.

When an educated person's expectations are crushed they are in a position to protest in novel and new ways. An educated person without a job can make a very good criminal.

This has always been a problem in PNG. Without trying to sound like an old fart it was a problem before independence.

Educated people then who couldn't get work were unsatisfied with village life and drifted to the towns and caused all sorts of innovative problems. People who had done a few years in primary school and thought they were educated did the same thing. Among other things they filled up the squatter settlements around the towns.

If you are going to improve education services so more people become educated you also have to concurrently improve the job opportunities for them.

You can't have one without the other I'm afraid.

Education may not be the only thing that help solves our social issues but education is the thing this country needs in order to progress.

Education...quality education could potentially relieve us from the tentacles of our Melanesian Way's demons. So let us all support good quality education!

At the very least, give the developing minds of today the tools with which to be creative and productive at any level of society.

That means tuning - up, not dumbing - down.

It also means running counter to the history makers who bestowed such a state of rottenness upon the nation's educational pathways.

Everyone deserves the right to be a reader, and thusly to partake of what is written, and to contribute to the body of knowledge.

Maybe its right to say that education is the ideal key in solving all those social issues we have going on in the nation today.

However, that is not exactly true, history has shown that some of those taking part in corrupted behaviors are the highly educated elites.

We can be educated but the major issue here is attitude. Everything comes down to attitude, how can we work for the better if we had attitude problems. If we cant respect ourselves then we wont respect others.

Anyway,since education is of great importance today, the government should contribute a great deal to it. Instead of looking at sports and whatnot, it should upgrade the level of education in schools especially those in the remote areas.

The most targeted of largely illiterate are girls and women so it might be better if government organisation set up some foundations to help them. Since, they are also the target of abuse and violence.

If education is the key to social problems, the government should develop schools in both rural and urban centres. The majority of the population lives in rural areas.

Most schools in rural areas don't have enough facilities to cater for the people in that area and there is no help from the government. Due to this, some don't get educated to another level. Only a few people are further educated, but some who have the potential aren't.

The educated people of the nation should be role models for their villages. However this isn't the case.

Highly educated people buy weapons and encourage their tribesmen to engage in tribal warfare. Highly educated people take alchohol and behave like stupids in public places.

Educated people are involved in street fights. Does that paint a good picture to the uneducated population? I don't think so.

Where I live, social issues were extremely high, that is tribal wars, holdups and alchohol related issues.

Both educated and uneducated people were involved. Education did not make a difference. What reduced the social issues was a couple and they are teachers.

All they did was taking care of the uneducated people that were involved in social issues. Supporting them financially and advising them to change, to become someone of use in the village.

The couple's good deed changed the people and reduced social issues. So,there are other ways of reducing social issues and not just education.

In the beginning, I thought education was the answer to all our social problems.

But my exposure to the ideas of Aristotle, Thomas Hobbes, Niccolo Machiavelli and other great philosophers have open my mind and warned me to be weary of human beings and our nature.

According to Marx and Hegel social issues and problems will continue to exist. If we find a solution then the problem will evolve and take a different form because the solutions are based on Western philosophy or they call it Hegalian-Marxist dialectics of Harmonization.

Any way, I will not bore you with dialectical philosophy.

Joe I like your idealism. It is common knowledge that teachers have that kind of influence on their students.

However, in reality we know and have seen that not all educated people contribute positively to society.

Education can change the world according to Mandela but the change can either be positive or negative.

Can education make an individual more moral? Will a university degree stop you from getting drunk and punching a person in the face? Will a degree stop you from helping your family to attack those who destroyed your garden?

Look at places like America, even though they have a highly educated population they still have a lot of social issues. Homelessness, gun related deaths, drugs, alcohol, people smuggling and so many more.

We have to understand human nature and the capabilities of a human being before we attempt to find a solution for social problems and issues.

Liklik tingting blo mi tasol.

Thank you.

If every one is educated there won’t be tribal fights or any social disorder or problems as mentioned by Joe.

Everyone knows what is good and what is bad for their society.

And that will result in reduction of the entire social problem in PNG.

Bernard - It very much depends on you and what you impart in them.

If your intention or the motive is different, then you will ruin the youngsters of your community. If you have a true heart and the concerns for the youngsters and the future of your community, the next generation, will be like you.

If you are an alcoholic, for example, your youngsters will follow you. Or if you have more marital affairs your juniors will do the same. And that’s where you impact your people and the future of your community.

Therefore, every contributors and readers of this site must at least do something practical. Yes, pen is mightier than sword but we can also practice what we write. I believe we can make difference.

Education is the most powerful weapon that can change the whole world as the great Mandela once said.

There is no guarantee that an educated person will be a better citizen.

Highly educated people buy weapons and encourage their tribesmen to engage in tribal warfare.

Educated people are sucking the country dry as we speak.

Thomas Hobbes says that man by nature are 'brutish' and 'egoistic'.

As someone from the higher education sector, I can do my best to educate my students as to what is right and what is wrong. However, the choice is in their hands.

Education whether formal though educational institutions or informal via the family or church is not the answer to social issues.

I like to say I have a solution but sadly I do not. A nightmare that all social scientist have.

I read in The Economist that about 10% of teachers in the US are incompetent; the teachers union is so powerful that they are shuffled around various schools.

Each school hopes to find a competent teacher in the next transfer.

What makes anyone believe that PNG is better than America in this respect.

In a previous comment I mentioned that headmasters are transferred around with no regard for their competence or honesty.

My adopted son never got to high school due to an incompetent and corrupt Deputy Headmaster. Despite the Headmaster making complaints written, phoned and verbal, the administration took no action.

I, with the School Board, forced the wriggling weakling to take well justified action (he really did wriggle).

The corrupt lazy teacher was then inflicted on a remote rural school. The said administrator was later seen to retire with great praise, no mention was made of the probable large number of students ruined by his maladministration.

The foreign educators coming to PNG these days do not want to have a conflicted existence, they will go with the flow; unless they wish to share in Dr Schram's experience.

Thanks Joe for the nice article. I believe education is the weapon that be can be used to chance Papua New Guinea.

Government must prioritise education if it wants to see PNG develop in the next 40 years.

Education is not a political football for politicians and political parties to be kicked around during election sessions nor as a political agenda to be included as one of their policies to be debated and lure votes in elections.

It must be a priority and has to come from the heart of the government.

Many successive governments over the last decades could have given priority to education just like the O’Neill government is doing.

Only Grand Chief Sir Peter Ipatas the Governor for Enga has put education on top of his priority list in his province for the last 18 years. Thumbs up to the Enga Governor.

Thank you to the O’Neill government in making education a priority for PNG this year and last year. We know as long your government is in place more people will be educated.

At the same time we play our individual role as detailed by Joe to get our youngsters know the importance of education and their social lives.

Joe, thumbs up for the great step you have taken to develop your youngsters. True that you have a heart for your people.

Yes, PNG needs people like you to develop the nation intellectually, economically and socially.

You have start it and i hope you will be on right tract. Keep doing well Joe.

I like the quote by the great Mandela that “education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world.”

PNG can change if education is first on its priority list.

I'm not convinced anyway. My statement was 'not all Papua New Guineans practice witchcraft and sorcery or sanguma'. And that still stands.

It was also a call on the government to review and amend the Sorcery Act of 1971 and support the police and court system in the country so that they can enforce them effectively without fear and favour.

Barbara - I really appreciate you for the nice comments. Yes, I believe in education as it’s a greatest tool that can do marvelous.

I have a heart for the young people and the future of my society up in the highlands of Papua New Guinea.

In 2011, when I was at school, I started a 'Waimin Elites Development Association’; aim at directing the minds and hearts of the young people towards education and personal development.

The association is comprised of the students from elementary to tertiary institutions in the country. We have an elected executive body that runs this small association.

We don’t have graduated members accept myself as the president of the association. All of them are still in schools. Five of them are at universities - two will be doing second year and three in first year at the University of Papua New Guinea and two in teachers college.

We have many students doing grade eleven, twelve and lower grades. More kids enrolled at elementary schools this year.

Annual meetings are held on 23 December. We invite local pastors from all churches in the community to pray and inspire us with the word of God.

We also invite leaders as the village representatives who also encourage us on better social lives. We conclude meetings with food we prepare as refreshment.

A day after the meeting we do awareness in our village and then we go out to the nearby villages.

Education, tribal warfare, HIV/AIDS, local economic activities like growing and looking after coffee, pigs etc are some of the topics we discuss with the people. We have done two times so far and were very successful.

I believe, through this association, the society will have greater number of educated elites who will bring peace and order in the community in the future.

If we, as individuals and government or NGOs and so forth, invest more in education and social development in all societies in the country, I believe, in the next 10 to 20 years PNG will be a better place to live. Educated population means healthy nation.

Let’s start doing something right now whether at national, local or village level. Change has to start from where you are. And we can make a difference.

Don’t blame people for the escalating tribal warfare if you as an individual can’t do anything to educated and develop your own tribesmen, women and kids.

Well said, indeed, Joe. The Prize is withdrawn with my humble apology for this and any other derogatory spear I may have levelled at you.

Please see my piece in response - if KJ puts it up - and I hope that perhaps we might begin communicating direct.

Well said, Joe. As a recent winner of Fowke's Ostrich Prize, you appear to be on the right track here.

Now you have to work out how you are going to "make it happen"!

The pen is mightier than the sword!

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.