« To take the truth to Oz is a longish journey | Main | Home »

23 February 2012

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Thank you Ross, education is the key...or how do we know what's a better choice?

As for proselytizing, I believe Somare et al (1975) successfully prevented us from eating of that forbidden fruit.

Speaking of fruits, what about vegetables and meat?

Our rural majority are still marginalised in the one area that will generate income and employment and be fundamentally empowering at the grass roots level.

Need I say the 'f' word?


Sorry Barbara, but that's the way it has been done for many years. 30 years ago, there weren't the "Campaign house" as described here, but the bribery of voters was. Back then the candidates had campaign funds that they spent on beer and promises.

So what's changed? Nothing, it appears. The voters are still gullible if they fall for these false promises.

Also, the system itself is subject to abuse through the tribal culture influence on the voting system.

We initially set up a pure Westminister type system but were told that the villagers were too politically immature to understand this.

So we changed to "first past the post", that is, the candidate who secured the gretest number of first preference votes was declared the winner, whether he/she secured a majority or not. What did this mean, the candidate from the biggest village in an electorate won.

So we changed again, but still the same practices of vote buying occur. Unfortunately, political education is linked to education. Until we can raise the education standards universally across the nation, a "hell-fire and brimstone" orator will still be beaten by someone who has more money.

Barbara, the problem with proselytizing about another way of doing things is that those expected to receive the message must have some way of understanding the concept being discussed.

The fact is that Australia was peremptorily ejected from PNG by Whitlam and Somare in 1975 before we had a proper opportunity to present and educate rural PNG people in any other political process than the traditional model (i.e. big man politics). It was clear that at the time, Somare and his elites did not want us to stay and cruel any chance he had of taking over and running the country in the way it has now developed.

Educated young PNG people must now work doubly hard to undo the current corrupt system that has been allowed to spread and inculcate the nation like a disease. What should be happening is that youth parliaments should be encouraged in all High Schools and funded by AusAID.

However who will provide the training, experience and encouragement for this to happen? Volunteers you say? Aiting yumi tupela lapun pinis liklik long wokabaut long bus tasol. But we could offer our skills and training if someone was interested in taking up the baton? Couldn’t we?

Thanks for this excellent coverage of what is going on in Simbu as regards the coming elections.

I'm not surprised, just saddened!

What can be done to change matters?

One can see the money that should be going into maintaining schools, hospitals, police stations etc being used to buy all these bribes, food, grog, sex,videos, mobile phones,school fees,pigs for funerals,free rides to town, bride price for the politicians many wives, etc etc etc.

Simbu used to be noted for its very clever people with piles of leadership skills. Surely there could be one man or woman found who could stand up to this corrupt culture which you have described!

PNG is doomed if something can't be done to stop all this corruption which has worked its way through all levels of society.

What did the traditional society do about greed?

They need a good old fashioned "hell-fire and brimstone" orator who can stand up in the market place and condemn what is going on.

Until that happens I'm afraid Simbu is doomed.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

My Photo
Blog powered by TypePad
Member since 02/2006